Full Text Transcript
13
I C L S L
NSURANCE LAIMS FOR OSS OF TOCK AND OSS
P
OF ROFIT
BASIC CONCEPTS
A. 1. Claim for Loss of Stock
Claim for loss of stock can be studied under two heads:
a. Total Loss:
Amount of claim = Actual loss (If goods are fully insured but the amount of claim is
restricted to the policy amount).
b. Partial Loss:
I) Without Average clause:-
Claim =Lower of actual Loss or Sum Insured
II) With Average Clause:-
Claim = Loss of stock x sum insured / Insurable amount (Total Cost)
B. 2. Claim for Loss of Profit
The Loss of Profit Policy normally covers the following items:
(1) Loss of net profit
(2) Standing charges.
(3) Any increased cost of working
Gross Profit:
Net profit +Insured Standing charges OR
Insured Standing charges – Net Trading Loss (If any) X Insured Standing charges/All
standing charges of business
Net Profit: The net trading profit (exclusive of all capital) receipts and accretion and all
outlay properly (chargeable to capital) resulting from the business of the Insured at the
premises after due provision has been made for all standing and other charges including
depreciation.
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
Insurance Claims for Loss of Stock and Loss of Profit
Insured Standing Charges: Interest on Debentures, Mortgage Loans and Bank
Overdrafts, Rent, Rates and Taxes (other than taxes which form part of net profit) Salaries
of Permanent Staff and Wages to Skilled Employees, Boarding and Lodging of resident
Directors and/or Manager, Directors’ Fees, Unspecified Standing Charges [not exceeding
5% (five per cent) of the amount recoverable in respect of Specified Standing Charges].
Rate of Gross Profit: The rate of Gross Profit earned on turnover during the financial
year immediately before the date of damage.
Annual Turnover: The turnover during the twelve months immediately before the
damage.
Standard Turnover: The turnover during that period in the twelve months immediately
before the date of damage which corresponds with the Indemnity Period.
Indemnity Period: The period beginning with the occurrence of the damage and ending
not later than twelve months.
The insurance for Loss of Profit is limited to loss of gross profit due to
(i) reduction in turnover, and
(ii) increase in the cost of working.
Question 1
Significance of ‘Average Clause’ in a fire insurance policy. (November, 2001)
Answer
In order to discourage under-insurance, fire insurance policies often include an average
clause. The effect of these clause is that if the insured value of the subject matter concerned
is less than the total cost then the average clause will apply, that is, the loss will be limited to
that proportion of the loss as the insured value bears to the total cost.
The actual claim amount would therefore be determined by the following formula:
Insured value
Claim= ×Loss suffered
Totalcost
For example, if stock worth Rs. 4 lakhs is insured for Rs. 3 lakhs only and the loss incurred
due to fire amounts to Rs. 1,80,000, the claim admitted by the insurer will be Rs. 1,80,000 x
3,00,000/4,00,000 =Rs. 1,35,000.
The average clause applies only when the insured value is less than the total value of the insured
subject matter.
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
13.2
Accounting
Question 2
X Ltd. has insured itself under a loss of profit policy for Rs. 3,63,000. The indemnity period
under the policy is six months. On 1st September, 2010 a fire occurred in the factory of X Ltd.
and the normal business was affected upto 1st March, 2011.
The following information is compiled for the year ended on 31st March, 2010:
Rs.
Sales 20,00,000
Insured standing charges 2,40,000
Uninsured standing charges 20,000
Net profit 1,20,000
Following further details of turnover are furnished.
(a) Turnover during the period of 12 months ending on the date of fire was 22,00,000.
(b) Turnover during the period of interruption was Rs. 2,25,000.
(c) Actual turnover during the period from 1.9.2009 to 1.3.2010 during the preceding year
corresponding to the indemnity period was Rs. 7,50,000.
X Ltd. spent an amount of Rs. 40,000 as additional cost of working during the indemnity
period. On account of this additional expenditure:
(a) There was a saving of Rs. 15,000 in insured standing charges during the period of
indemnity.
(b) Reduced turnover avoided was Rs. 1,00,000. i.e. but for his expenditure, the turnover after
the date of fire would have been only Rs. 1,25,000.
A special clause in the policy stipulates that owing to the reasons acceptable to the insurer
under the special circumstances the following increases are to be made:
(a) Increase of turnover standard and actual by 10%.
(b) Increase in rate of gross profit by 2% from previous year’s level.
X Ltd. asks you to compute the claim for loss of profit. All calculations should be to the nearest
rupee. (May, 1999)
Answer
Computation of loss of profit for insurance claim
(1) Rate of gross profit
Net profit for the last financial year + Insured standing charges
×100
Turnover for the last financial year
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
13.3
Insurance Claims for Loss of Stock and Loss of Profit
Rs.1,20,000+ Rs. 2,40,000
= ×100 18%
Rs, 20,00,000
Add: Adjustment for increase in gross profit rate= 2%
20%
(2) Calculation of short sales:
Rs.
Turnover from 1.9.2009 to 1.3.2010 7,50,000
Add: Adjustment for increase in turnover _75,000
Adjusted turnover 8,25,000
Less: Actual turnover from 1.9.2010 to 1.3.2011 2,25,000
Short sales 6,00,000
(3) Additional expenses:
Rs.
(i) Actual expenses 40,000
(ii) Gross profit on sale generated by additional expenses
[(20/100)x Rs. 1,00,000] 20,000
Gross profit on annual adjusted turnover
(iii) Additional expenses ×
Gross profit on annual adjusted turnover + Uninsured standing charges
20% on Rs. 24,20,000*
= Rs.40,000×
(20% on Rs. 24,20,000)+Rs. 20,000
Rs.4,84,000
= Rs. 40,000 x = Rs. 38,413
Rs.5,04,000
Least of the above three figures i.e. Rs. 20,000 is allowable.
* Rs. 22,00,000 x (110/100)
(4) Amount of claim before application of average clause
Rs.
Gross profit on short sales (20% on Rs. 6,00,000) 1,20,000
Add: Allowable additional expenses 20,000
1,40,000
Less: Saving in insured standing charges 15,000
1,25,000
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
13.4
Accounting
(5) Application of average clause
Rs.
Annual turnover i.e. turnover from 1.9.2009 to 31.8 2010 22,00,000
Add: Adjustment for increase in turnover (10% of Rs. 22,00,000) 2,20,000
24,20,000
Gross profit on annual adjusted turnover (20% on Rs. 24,20,000) 4,84,000
Loss of profit policy value 3,63,000
Since the policy-value is less than gross profit on adjusted annual turnover, the average
clause is applicable.
Hence the amount of claim =Rs. 1,25,000x (Rs. 3,63,000/Rs. 4,84,000)
=Rs. 93,750
Question 3
CCL wants to take up a loss of profit policy. Turnover during the current year is expected to
increase by 20%. The company will avail overdraft facilities from its bank @ 15% interest to
boost up the sales. The average daily overdraft balance will be around Rs. 3 lakh. All other
fixed expenses will remain same. The following further details are also available from the
previous year’s account.
Rs.
Total variable expenses 24,00,000
Fixed expenses:
Salaries 3,30,000
Rent, Rates, and Taxes 30,000
Travelling expenses 50,000
Postage, Telegram, Telephone 60,000
Director’s fees 10,000
Audit fees 20,000
Miscellaneous income 70,000
Net Profit 4,20,000
Determine the amount of policy to be taken for the current year. (November, 2001)
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
13.5
Insurance Claims for Loss of Stock and Loss of Profit
Answer
Insurance Policy
Rs.
Gross profit on the basis of last year’s sales 8,50,000
Add: 20% for increase of turnover 1,70,000
10,20,000
Add: Increased standing charges (interest on overdraft) 45,000
Policy to be taken for current year 10,65,000
Working Notes:
1. Profit and Loss Account for the previous year
Rs. Rs.
To Variable expenses 24,00,000 By Sales 32,50,000
To Fixed expenses 5,00,000 By Misc. income 70,000
To Net profit 4,20,000 ________
33,20,000 33,20,000
2. Gross profit of the previous year
Rs.
Sales 32,50,000
Less: Variable expenses 24,00,000
8,50,000
Question 4
Mr. A prepares accounts on 30th September each year, but on 31st December, 2011 fire
destroyed the greater part of his stock. Following information was collected from his book:
Rs.
Stock as on 1.10.2011 29,700
Purchases from 1.10.2011 to 31.12.2011 75,000
Wages from 1.10.2011 to 31.12.2011 33,000
Sales from 1.10.2011 to 31.12.2011 1,40,000
The rate of gross profit is 33.33% on cost. Stock to the value of Rs. 3,000 was salvaged.
Insurance policy was for Rs. 25,000 and claim was subject to average clause.
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
13.6
Accounting
Additional informations:
(i) Stock in the beginning was calculated at 10% less than cost.
(ii) A plant was installed by firm’s own worker. He was paid Rs. 500, which was included in
wages.
(iii) Purchases include the purchase of the plant for Rs. 5,000
You are required to calculate the claim for the loss of stock. (November, 2002)
Answer
Computation of claim for loss of stock:
Rs.
Stock on the date of fire i.e. 31.12.2011 (Refer working note) 30,500
Less: Salvaged stock _3,000
Loss of stock 27,500
Amount of claim
Insured value
= ×loss of stock
Total cost of stock on the date offire
Rs.25,000
= ×Rs.27,500 = 22,541
Rs. 30,500
Working Note:
Memorandum trading account can be prepared for the period from 1.10.2011 to 31.12.2011 to
compute the value of stock on 31.12.2011.
Memorandum Trading Account
for period from 1.10.2011 to 31.12.2011
Rs. Rs. Rs.
To Opening stock 33,000 By Sales 1,40,000
(Rs. 29,700x100/90) By Closing stock 30,500
To Purchases 75,000 (balancing figure)
Less: Cost of plant _5,000 70,000
To Wages 33,000
Less: Wages paid for plant __500 32,500
To Gross profit 35,000
(33.33% on cost or 25% on
sales) _______ _______
1,70,500 1,70,500
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
13.7
Insurance Claims for Loss of Stock and Loss of Profit
Question 5
On account of a fire on 15th June, 2011 in the business house of a company, the working
remained disturbed upto 15th December 2011 as a result of which it was not possible to affect
any sales. The company had taken out an insurance policy with an average clause against
consequential losses for Rs. 1,40,000 and a period of 7 months has been agreed upon as
indemnity period. An increased of 25% was marked in the current year’s sales as compared to
the last year. The company incurred an additional expenditure of Rs. 12,000 to make sales
possible and made a saving of Rs. 2,000 in the insured standing charges.
Rs.
Actual sales from 15th June, 2011 to 15th Dec, 2011 70,000
Sales from 15th June 2010 to 15th Dec 2010 2,40,000
Net profit for last financial year 80,000
Insured standing charges for the last financial year 70,000
Total standing charges for the last financial year 1,20,000
Turnover for the last financial year 6,00,000
Turnover for one year : 16 June 2010 to 15 June 2011 5,60,000 (November, 2003)
Answer
(1) Calculation of short sales:
Rs.
Sales for the period 15.6.2010 to 15.12.2010 2,40,000
Add: 25% increase in sales _60,000
Estimated sales in current year 3,00,000
Less: Actual sales from 15.6.2011 to 15.12.2011 _70,000
Short sales 2,30,000
(2) Calculation of gross profit:
Net profit + Insured standing charges
Gross profit = ×100
Turnover
Rs. 80,000+Rs. 70,000
= ×100
Rs. 6,00,000
Rs.1,50,000
= ×100
Rs.6,00,000
= 25%
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
13.8
Accounting
(3) Calculation of loss of profit:
Rs. 2,30,000 x 25% =Rs. 57,500
(4) Calculation of claim for increased cost of working :
Least of the following:-
(i) Actual expense =Rs. 12,000
(ii) Expenditure x (Net profit+ Insured standing charges)/(Net profit + Total standing
charges)
Rs. 80,000+Rs. 70,000
=Rs. 12,000 x = Rs. 9,000
Rs. 80,000+Rs. 1,20,000
(iii) Gross profit on sales generated due to additional expenses
=Rs. 70,000x 25% = Rs. 17,500
Rs. 9,000 being the least, shall be the increased cost of working.
(5) Calculation of total loss of profit:
Rs.
Loss of profit 57,500
Add: Increased cost of working 9,000
66,500
Less: Saving in standing charges 2,000
64,500
(6) Calculation of insurable amount = Adjusted sales x G. P. rate:
Rs.
Turnover from 16.6.2010 to 15.6.2011 5,60,000
Add: 25% increase 1,40,000
Adjusted sales 7,00,000
Insurable amount= Rs. 7,00,000 x 25% = Rs. 1,75,000
(7) Total claim for consequential loss of profit:
Insured amount
Total claim= ×Total loss of profit
Insurable amount
Rs. 1,40,000
Total claim= x Rs. 64,500 = Rs. 51,600
Rs. 1,75,000
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
13.9
Insurance Claims for Loss of Stock and Loss of Profit
Alternatively claim for increased cost of working can also be calculated applying the
following method (first three calculations will be the same as in the earlier alternative).
(8) Calculation of claim for increased cost of working:
Least of the following :-
(i) Actual expense= Rs. 12,000
Gross profit on adjusted turnover
(ii) Expenditure x
Gross profit as above + Uninsured standing charges
(25/100) x Rs. 7,00,000
Rs. 12,000 x = Rs. 9,333 approx.
[(25/100) x Rs. 7,00,000]+ Rs. 50,000
Where,
Adjusted turnover Rs.
Turnover from 16.06.2010 to 15.06.2011 5,60,000
Add: 25% increase 1,40,000
7,00,000
(iii) Gross profit on sales generated due to additional expenditure =25% x Rs. 70,000
= Rs. 17,500.
Rs. 9,333 being the least, shall be the increased cost of working.
(9) Calculation of total loss of profit
Rs.
Loss of profit 57,500
Add: Increased cost of working 9,333
66,833
Less: Saving in insured standing charges 2,000
64,833
(10) Calculation of insurable amount:
Adjusted turnover x G.P. rate.
= Rs. 7,00,000 x 25% =Rs. 1,75,000
(11) Total claim for consequential loss of profit:
Insured amount
= ×Total loss of profit
Insurableamount
Rs. 1,40,000
= x Rs. 64,833 = Rs. 51,866.40
Rs. 1,75,000
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
13.10
Accounting
Question 6
On 20th October, 2009, the godown and business premises of Aman Ltd. were affected by fire.
From the salvaged accounting records, the following information is available.
`
Stock of goods @ 10% lower than cost as on 31st March,09 2,16,000
Purchases less returns (1.4.09 to 20.10.09) 2,80,000
Sales less returns (1.4.09 to 20.10.09) 6,20,000
Additional information:
(1) Sales upto 20th October, 09 includes ` 80,000 for which goods had not been dispatched.
(2) Purchases upto 20th October, 09 did not include ` 40,000 for which purchase invoices
had not been received from suppliers, though goods have been received in Godown.
(3) Past records show the gross profit rate of 25%.
(4) The value of goods salvaged from fire ` 31,000.
(5) Aman Ltd. has insured their stock for ` 1,00,000.
Compute the amount of claim to be lodged to the insurance company. (November, 2010)
Answer
Memorandum Trading A/c
(1.4.09 to 20.10.09)
Particulars (`) Particulars (`)
To Opening stock (Refer W.N.) 2,40,000 By Sales 5,40,000
(`6,20,000 – `80,000)
To Purchases 3,20,000 By Closing stock 1,55,000
(` 2,80,000 + ` 40,000) (bal. fig.)
To Gross profit
(` 5,40,000 x 25%) 1,35,000
6,95,000 6,95,000
`
Stock on the date of fire (i.e. on 20.10.2009) 1,55,000
Less: Stock salvaged (31,000)
Stock destroyed by fire 1,24,000
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
13.11
Insurance Claims for Loss of Stock and Loss of Profit
Loss of stock
Insurance claim = × Amount of policy
Value of stock on the date of fire
= 1,24,000 × 1,00,000 = ` 80,000
1,55,000
Working Note:
Stock as on 1st April, 2009 was valued at 10% lower than cost.
Hence, original cost of the stock as on 1st April, 2009 would be
2,16,000
= × 100 = ` 2,40,000
90
EXERCISES
1. Sony Ltd.’s. trading and profit and loss account for the year ended 31st December, 2010 were as follows:
Trading and Profit and Loss Account for the year ended 31.12.2010
Rs. Rs.
Opening stock 20,000 Sales 10,00,000
Purchases 6,50,000 Closing stock 90,000
Manufacturing expenses 1,70,000
Gross profit 2,50,000 _______
10,90,000 10,90,000
Administrative expenses 80,000 Gross profit 2,50,000
Selling expenses 20,000
Finance charges 1,00,000
Net profit 50,000 _______
2,50,000 2,50,000
The company had taken out a fire policy for Rs. 3,00,000 and a loss of profits policy for Rs. 1,00,000 having an
indemnity period of 6 months. A fire occurred on 1.4.2011 at the premises and the entire stock were gutted with nil
salvage value. The net quarter sales i.e. 1.4.2011 to 30.6.2011 was severely affected. The following are the other
information:
Sales during the period 1.1.2011 to 31.3.2011 2,50,000
Purchases during the period 1.1.2011 to 31.3.2011 3,00,000
Manufacturing expenses 1.1.2011 to 31.3.2011 70,000
Sales during the period 1.4.2011 to 30.6.2011 87,500
Standing charges insured 50,000
Actual expense incurred after fire 60,000
The general trend of the industry shows an increase of sales by 15% and decrease in GP by 5% due to increased
cost.
Ascertain the claim for stock and loss of profit.
(Hints: Stock destroyed by fire Rs. 2,60,000; and loss of profit rs.15,000)
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
13.12
Accounting
2. On 30th June, 2011, accidental fire destroyed a major part of the stocks in the godown of Jay associates. Stocks
costing Rs. 30,000 could be salvaged but not their stores ledgers. A fire insurance policy was in force under which
the sum insured was Rs. 3,50,000. From available records, the following information was retrieved:
(1) Total of sales invoices during the period April-June amounted to Rs. 30,20,000. An analysis showed that
goods of the value of Rs. 3,00,000 had been returned by the customers before the date of fire.
(2) Opening stock on 1.4.2011 was Rs. 2,20,000 including stocks of value of Rs. 20,000 being lower of cost
and net value subsequently realised.
(3) Purchases between 1.4.2011 and 30.6.2011 were Rs. 21,00,000
(4) Normal gross profit rate was 33-1/3% on sales.
(5) A sum of Rs. 30,000 was incurred by way of fire fighting expenses on the day of the fire.
Prepare a statement showing the insurance claim recoverable.
(Hints: Claim Rs. = Rs. 3,29,000)
3. A fire occurred in the premises of Agni on 25th August, 2011 when a large part of the stock was destroyed.
Salvage was Rs. 15,000. Agni gives you the following information for the period of January 1, 2011 to August 25th,
2011:
(a) Purchases Rs. 85,000.
(b) Sales Rs. 90,000
(c) Goods costing Rs. 5,000 were taken by Agni for personal use.
(d) Cost price of stock on January 1, 2011 was Rs. 40,000
Over the past few years, Agni has been selling goods at a consistent gross profit margin of 33-1/3%.
The insurance policy was for Rs. 50,000. It included an average clause.
Agni asks you to prepare a statement of claim to be made on the insurance company.
(Hints: Admissible claim Rs. 37,500)
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
13.13